The dramatic rise in bank failures over the last decade has led to a search for leading indicators so that costly bailouts might be avoided. Data envelopment analysis is a novel decision making tool based on the principle of linear programming to compare the relative operational efficiency of a set of comparable decision making units even with multiple inputs and outputs. A comparison of parametric and nonparametric estimation methods. This paper attempts to combine the virtues of both approaches in a unified framework. Data envelopment analysis dea, a nonparametric mathematical programming approach to productive efficiency analysis, envelops all observed data. Roman and gotiu 2017 describe dea as a non parametric method of estimating production efficiency frontiers. The model structure of nonparametric models is not specified a priori. Data was collected from a sample of 180 farmers using multistage. Nonparametric models differ from parametric models in that the model structure is not specified a priori but is instead determined from data. Data envelopment analysis dea has been used and continues.
Data envelopment analysis applications in primary health. Although dea has a strong link to production theory in economics, the tool is also used for benchmarking in operations management, where a set of. In this study, the main nonparametrical data envelopment analysis method is presented wu, fan, zhou, zhou, 2012. Our findings show non governmental microfinance institutions particularly. In this paper, we show that dea can be alternatively interpreted as nonparametric leastsquares regression subject to shape constraints on the frontier and sign constraints on residuals. Nonparametric estimation of environmental efficiency using. To achieve the first objective, the study engages a nonparametric method characterized as a variable return to scaledata envelopment analysis vrtsdea. Paper presented at a conference on new uses of dea in management, austin texas. Roman and gotiu 2017 describe dea as a nonparametric method of estimating production efficiency frontiers. Since its inception, stochastic data envelopment analysis sdea has found applications in vast and diverse areas of management science. A nonparametric bootstrapdata envelopment analysis. In this paper we show that dea can be alternatively interpreted as nonparametric least squares regression subject to shape constraints on frontier and sign constraints on residuals. Depending on the level of the data you plan to examine e. This analysis method is basically a linear pro grammingbased technique used for measuring the relative performance of organisational units where the presence of multiple inputs and.
It has generally been argued that parametric statistics should not be applied to data with non normal distributions. Nondiscretionary factors in data envelopment analysis. As the table below shows, parametric data has an underlying normal distribution which allows for more conclusions to be drawn as the shape can be mathematically described. Existing measures of performance are limited to historical ratio analyses without any benchmarks. It is used to empirically measure productive efficiency of decision making units dmus. Nonparametric approaches nonparametric approaches 1. Parametric v nonparametric methods for data analysis. Nonparametric estimation of environmental efficiency using data envelopment analysis and free disposable hull. Non parametric estimation of environmental efficiency using data envelopment analysis and free disposable hull.
Nonparametric production analysis of pesticides use in the. Data envelopment analysis dea is a linear programming methodology to measure the efficiency of multiple decisionmaking units dmus when the production process presents a structure of multiple inputs and outputs. This guide describes a computer program which has been written to conduct data envelopment analyses dea. Efficiency estimation using a hybrid of data envelopment analysis and linear regression john dilip raj, ge capital retail finance abstract literature suggests two main approaches, parametric and nonparametric, for constructing efficiency frontiers using which efficiency scores of. Data envelopment analysis schweitzer fachinformationen. It uses linear programming to estimate the efficiency of multiple decisionmaking units and it is commonly used in production, management and economics. However, in the field of research the most commonly.
Nonparametric methods applied in the efficiency analysis of. The extent of resource use inefficiencies in cotton. Analysis dea, a nonparametric approach, is a powerful tool used for. The non parametric method of dea is presented in detail in section 3, along with developments and extensions of dea designed to overcome its main drawbacks. There is, however, a paucity of literature on the study of efficiency. Data envelopment analysis dea is known as a nonparametric mathematical programming approach to productive efficiency analysis. Dea is a relatively new nonparametric approach for evaluating the performance of a set of peer entities called decision making units dmus which convert multiple inputs into multiple outputs. Data envelopment analysis data envelopment analysis or dea 3, 4, 7 is an lp based technique for evaluating the relative e ciency of decision making units dmus. Hospital efficiency has hitherto been measured mainly by frontier analysis methods, either through non parametric data envelopment analysis dea or as parametric stochastic frontier analysis sfa. Utilizing the selected variables, such as unit cost and output, dea software. The non parametric property implies that this methodology does.
Charnes and cooper 1985 describe a nonparametric approach in such situations to measure efficiency and the technique is known as data envelopment analysis dea. Next, in section 4, the results are presented followed by a summary and. Hospital efficiency has hitherto been measured mainly by frontier analysis methods, either through nonparametric data envelopment analysis dea or as parametric stochastic frontier analysis sfa. Data envelopment analysis as nonparametric least squares. The literature of productive efficiency analysis is divided into two main branches. A monte carlo simulation comparing dea, sfa and two. This is a tutorial on data envelopment analysis 1 abstract data envelopment analysis dea is a linear programming based technique for measuring the relative performance of organisational units where the presence of multiple inputs and outputs makes comparisons difficult. Dec 15, 20 in the first stage a non parametric data envelopment analysis is used to model efficiencies as an explicit function of human labor, machinery, chemicals, fym farmyard manure, diesel fuel, electricity and water for irrigation energies.
Dea to calculate nonparametric measures of the value of the marginal product of pesticides. Nonparametric estimation of environmental efficiency. Data envelopment analysis dea is a nonparametric method that is widely used for relative efficiency and performance evaluation of the set of decisionmaking units dmus. Unlike parametric models, nonparametric models do not require the. A nonparametric bootstrapdata envelopment analysis approach for environmental policy planning and management of agricultural efficiency in eu countries author links open overlay panel pierluigi toma a pier paolo miglietta a giovanni zurlini b donatella valente b irene petrosillo b. Parametric versus nonparametric statistics in the analysis. While the quality of a banks management is generally acknowledged to be a key contributor to institutional collapse, it is usually excluded from earlywarning models for lack of a metric. Data envelopment analysis as nonparametric leastsquares. A nonparametric approach this paper endeavours to evaluate the extent of technical, pure technical and scale efficiencies of banking sector in tanzania using the nonparametric technique of data envelopment analysis. Oct 17, 2009 this study examines the cost efficiency of 39 microfinance institutions across africa, asia and the latin america using non parametric data envelopment analysis. A nonparametric bootstrapdata envelopment analysis approach. Computational aspects of data envelopment analysis.
Dea involves the use of linear programming methods to construct a nonparametric piecewise surface or frontier over the data, so as to be able to calculate efficiencies relative to this surface. Efficiency evaluation of european financial cooperative. Denote this number by, called the number of plus signs. Results of the first phase revealed that technical efficiency of all the islamic banks were very high, amounting to. Explanations social research analysis parametric vs. Two of the most important nonparametric methods used are the stochastic frontier analysis sfa and the data envelopment analysis dea approach. A nonparametric approach abstract the aims of this study is to observe the efficiency of prominent microfinance banks working in pakistan as the microfinance banks not only playing its role in poverty alleviation but also becomes an.
Efficiency of resource use by rice farmers in ebonyi state. It is used to empirically measure productive efficiency of decision making units or dmus. Inferential statistical procedures generally fall into two possible categorizations. A non parametric bootstrap data envelopment analysis approach for environmental policy planning and management of agricultural efficiency in eu countries author links open overlay panel pierluigi toma a pier paolo miglietta a giovanni zurlini b donatella valente b irene petrosillo b. Empirical research has demonstrated that mannwhitney generally has greater power than the ttest unless data are sampled from the normal. The main disadvantage of nonparametric approaches is their deterministic nature. Therefore, questions are often asked about the performance of these hospitals. Objectives public hospitals in nepal account for a major share of the total health budget. Pdf data envelopment analysis dea, a nonparametric mathematical programming approach to productive efficiency analysis, envelops all. This paper examines an encompassing semiparametric frontier model that combines the deatype nonparametric frontier, which satisfies monotonicity and concavity, with. Evaluating the efficiency of pakistani microfinance banks. There are two types of test data and consequently different types of analysis.
Dea is a relatively new non parametric approach for evaluating the performance of a set of peer entities called decision making units dmus which convert multiple inputs into multiple outputs. In this project we have used data envelopment analysis dea, which is a nonparametric method in optimization and economics to estimate production frontiers of decision making units dmus. The objective of this study is to explore the trends in inputs, outputs and productivity changes in nepalese public hospitals. A non parametric approach abstract the aims of this study is to observe the efficiency of prominent microfinance banks working in pakistan as the microfinance banks not only playing its role in poverty alleviation but also becomes an important stakeholder that becomes a cause of. As an original non parametric approach of efficiency measurement, data envelopment analysis has been introduced by charnes 15. Data were analyzed in two different phases considering different inputoutput variables. The dea model has been applied to estimate the technical efficiency of annual crops such as turmeric, rice. Pdf data envelopment analysis as nonparametric leastsquares. Data envelopment analysis, also known as dea, is a non parametric method for performing frontier analysis.
Data envelopment analysis of the effieincy frontier for the results achived by. Dea is a nonparametric method which identifies an efficiency frontier on which. Data envelopment analysis, for instance, does not distinguish between technical inefficiency and statistical noise effects. In this project we have used data envelopment analysis dea, which is a non parametric method in optimization and economics to estimate production frontiers of decision making units dmus. The term nonparametric is not meant to imply that such models completely lack parameters but that the number and nature of the parameters are flexible and not fixed in advance a histogram is a simple nonparametric estimate of a. Deabased hypothesis tests for comparing two groups of decision. Tutorial ali emrouznejads data envelopment analysis. This study examines the cost efficiency of 39 microfinance institutions across africa, asia and the latin america using nonparametric data envelopment analysis. Dea is a non parametric method which identifies an efficiency frontier on which. In this study, the main non parametrical data envelopment analysis method is presented wu, fan, zhou, zhou, 2012.
Data envelopment analysis dea is known as a nonparametric mathematical programming approach to productive ef. Mar 09, 2018 data envelopment analysis dea is a nonparametric method in operations research and economics for the estimation of production frontiers. Dea allows multiple inputsoutputs to be considered at the same time without any assumption on data distribution. We present ranking methods for performance evaluation in sdea using the notion of stochastic ordering that takes random fluctuations of the efficiency score into account. To achieve the first objective, the study engages a non parametric method characterized as a variable return to scale data envelopment analysis vrtsdea.
A data envelopment analysis abstract this study investigated the technical and scale efficiencies in rice production by rice farmers in ebonyi state nigeria using the data envelopment analysis dea. Selecting between parametric and nonparametric analyses. A study project on real life application of data envelopement analysis. While the quality of a banks management is generally acknowledged to be a key contributor to institutional collapse, it is usually excluded from. A comparison of parametric and nonparametric efficiency measures. Upstream technical efficiency and its determinants. Data envelopment analysis dea is a nonparametric method in operations research and economics for the estimation of production frontiers. It is based on maximization of a weighted sum of outputs produced by the unit under evaluation divided by the weighted sum of inputs of the same unit, and the assumption that this ratio for all other units. The most important representative of the nonparametric methods is, without doubt, data envelopment analysis dea. Paper 18722014 efficiency estimation using a hybrid of data envelopment analysis and linear regression john dilip raj, ge capital retail finance abstract literature suggests two main approaches, parametric and non parametric, for constructing efficiency frontiers using which efficiency scores of other units can be based. Although dea has a strong link to production theory in economics, the tool is also used for benchmarking in operations management, where a set of measures is selected. Paper 18722014 efficiency estimation using a hybrid of. Nonparametric statistics includes nonparametric descriptive statistics, statistical models, inference, and statistical tests.
Data envelopment analysis dea and free disposal hull fdh methods 11. The field of productive efficiency analysis is currently divided between two main paradigms. Data envelopment analysis dea is a nonparametric, deterministic alternative to several efficiency measurement techniques, such as the costeffectiveness ratio, corrected ordinary least squares or stochastic frontier analysis. Murillozamorano, 2004, with two key references to the established approaches. Because the non parametric data envelopment analysis dea approach is easier to be implemented, it has become a popular technique used in efficiency analysis, 5.
However, in the field of research the most commonly practiced approach is data envelopment analysis. A nonparametric analytical method for benchmarking a group of entities. Review on parametric and nonparametric methods of efficiency. The nonparametric property implies that this methodology does. Paper 18722014 efficiency estimation using a hybrid of data. This study examines the cost efficiency of 39 microfinance institutions across africa, asia and the latin america using non parametric data envelopment analysis. Nitrogen, phosphate, and herbicide use are three main environmental problems caused by agriculture. In this paper we show that dea can be interpreted as nonparametric least squares regression subject to shape constraints on frontier. Parametric v nonparametric methods for data analysis the bmj.
A method commonly used in statistics to model and analyze ordinal or nominal data with small sample sizes. However, when multiple inputs and outputs are encountered, data envelopment. The nonparametric method is a method of using linear programming to measure the relative efficiency of a number of decisionmaking units through the identification of the optimal mix of. Data envelopment analysis dea, initially introduced by charnes et al. Pdf stochastic nonparametric envelopment of panel data. Efficiency evaluation of public hospitals in saudi arabia. The term non parametric applies to the statistical method used to analyse data, and is not a property of the data. In many cases the performance nonpro t and government organizational units is very di cult to compare. The results of applying dea to a data set of more than 100 english universities are presented in section 4. Dea involves the use of linear programming methods to construct a non parametric piecewise surface or frontier over the data, so as to be able to calculate efficiencies relative to this surface. The origins of dea date back to the seminal paper by.
Data envelopment analysis models in nonhomogeneous. Efficiency of resource use by rice farmers in ebonyi state, south east nigeria. Data envelopment analysis dea and free dis posal hull fdh methods 11. In the first stage a nonparametric data envelopment analysis is used to model efficiencies as an explicit function of human labor, machinery, chemicals, fym farmyard manure, diesel fuel, electricity and water for irrigation energies.
The term nonparametric applies to the statistical method used to analyse data, and is not a property of the data. Halkos, tzeremes, 2009 and its application on a group of 42 companies the headquarters of a top commercial bank in romania s. The main disadvantage of non parametric approaches is their deterministic nature. A nonparametric data envelopment analysis approach for. Brd groupe societe generale, based on the information gained in the years 20162017. In the case of randomized trials, we are typically interested in how an endpoint, such as blood pressure or pain, changes following. Pdf data envelopment analysis as nonparametric least. Parametric tests rely on the assumption that the data you are testing resembles a. Table 1 presents a classification of the frontier estimation literature into parametric vs. Data envelopment analysis is a novel decision making tool based on the principle of linear programming to compare the relative operational efficiency of a set of comparable. Performance evaluation of dmus is at the heart of dea, both stochastic and deterministic. Using nonparametric technical data envelopment analysis. Dea has been used for both production and cost data. Because the nonparametric data envelopment analysis dea approach is easier to be implemented, it has become a popular technique used in efficiency analysis, 5.
1430 467 1297 108 82 475 631 1220 1153 925 1237 1351 1086 859 872 980 643 931 1351 566 192 1157 1590 1332 733 777 660 763 600 1094 1028 910 734 1218 676 942 1045 261 956